CNN
—
If Joe Biden loses November’s election, history will record that it took just 10 minutes to destroy a presidency.
It was clear a political disaster was about to unfold as soon as the 81-year-old commander in chief stiffly shuffled on stage in Atlanta to stand eight feet from ex-President Donald Trump at what may turn into the most fateful presidential debate in history.
Objectively, Biden produced the weakest performance since John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon started the tradition of televised debates in 1960 — then, as on Thursday, in a television studio with no audience.
Minutes into the showdown, hosted by CNN, a full-blown Democratic panic was underway at the idea of heading into the election with such a diminished figure at the top of the ticket.
Biden’s chief debate coach, Ron Klain, famously argues that “while you can lose a debate at any time, you can only win it in the first 30 minutes.” By that standard, the president’s showing was devastating. The tone of the evening was set well before the half hour.
It is too early to say how voters will respond and whether the president can rescue himself. But Biden barely beat Trump in key battleground states in the middle of a pandemic in 2020. His approval rating was below 40% before the debate, when he was at best neck-and-neck with his rival in the polls. It would only take a few thousand voters to desert him to put Trump back in the White House.
There has been no public sign that Biden is unable to fulfill the duties of the presidency, which include tough decisions on national security. He has just returned from two grueling foreign trips, for instance. But on Thursday’s evidence, his ability to communicate with the country – and even to sell his own vision for a second term – is severely compromised.
If the debate was the president’s best chance to turn around a tight race with Trump, which has him in deep peril of losing reelection, it was a failure. Biden ended the night with the Democratic Party in crisis with serious conversations taking place behind the scenes among senior figures over whether his candidacy is now sustainable, two months before the Democratic National Convention.
The ex-president didn’t avoid his own disqualifying issues. He was uncouth and divisive. He spouted outrageous falsehoods about his own presidency, his attempt to steal the last election, and sometimes lapsed into gibberish himself, especially when asked about climate change. He blatantly lied about his role in the mob attack by his supporters on the US Capitol on January 6, 2021.
The twice-impeached convicted felon repeatedly declined to say that he would accept the result of the 2024 election if he lost and made sweeping, vague and often illogical claims that US enemies overseas would bend to his will just because of his personality. The former president also struggled to parry Biden’s arguments that he’d slash taxes for rich Americans and leave workers struggling, and he was wobbly on policy, just as he was in the White House.
By the time the aged rivals slipped into a bitter debate about who was the best golfer, it was not hard to understand why voters have long told pollsters that they want no part of the choice they have been offered this year.
Austin Steele/CNN
Former President Donald Trump and President Joe Biden debate at CNN’s Atlanta studios on June 27, 2024.
But Biden has rooted his reelection in the idea that he is the last thing standing between America and a second Trump presidency that would destroy democracy and usher in an unprecedented era of American autocracy. Voters who take him at his word could not help but be alarmed at his abject debate showing.
Biden’s voice was weak, at times reduced to a whisper. Early on, the president’s answers drifted into incoherence. He missed openings to jab Trump on abortion — the top Democratic talking point — and meandered into highlighting his own biggest political liability, immigration. “We finally beat Medicare,” Biden said at one point, lapsing into confused silence. It was the kind of debate gaffe that Democrats had hoped to avoid. Worse, while Trump spoke, Biden often watched, his mouth gaping open, exacerbating an impression of a president cruelly diminished. His bravura battering of Trump in a debate four years ago was a distant memory.
To see a president struggle before millions of people watching on television all around the world was tough to see. As a matter of humanity, the personification of the ravages of age that await everyone was painful. Biden’s campaign revealed during the debate that he had been suffering from a cold. But by that time, the damage had already been done.
Biden had entered the debate facing a somber test — to prove to the majority of Americans who believe he is too old to serve that he is vital, energetic and up to fulfilling his duties in a second term that would end when he is 86. Instead, the president ended up validating those fears and potentially convincing many more voters that his faculties have decayed. The stumbling performance raised questions about the strategic choice Biden’s campaign made in pushing for a debate with Trump. It also completely undercut attempts by the White House and the campaign to talk up Biden’s heartiness behind the scenes. Memories of the president’s barnstorming State of the Union address in March, when he put many fears about his age to rest, have now been obliterated.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Former President Donald Trump, left, and President Joe Biden take part in the CNN presidential debate on Thursday, June 27.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
First lady Jill Biden, right, joins her husband as he talks with moderators Jake Tapper and Dana Bash after the debate.
Adam Rose/CNN
People gather on the floor of the post-debate “spin room,” which was held at Georgia Tech’s McCamish Pavilion across from CNN’s headquarters.
Austin Steele/CNN
The Bidens embrace after the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Trump and Biden were debating each other for the first time since 2020.
Tristen Rouse/CNN
People watch the debate at Union Pub in Washington, DC.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Photographers take photos of the candidates during the first of two commercial breaks.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Trump makes a point early in the debate. Trump launched his bid to reclaim the White House in November 2022, aiming to become only the second commander in chief to win two nonconsecutive terms.
Tristen Rouse/CNN
People watch the debate in Washington, DC.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Microphones were muted throughout the debate except for the candidate whose turn it was to speak.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Biden, at 81, is the oldest president to ever hold office. He would be 86 at the end of a second term.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Trump watches Biden answer a question.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Biden watches Trump during the debate’s first hour.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Trump exits the stage during one of the commercial breaks.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
The candidates levied personal attacks against each other as they sparred over the economy, immigration, abortion and more.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
With less than five months until the election, the stakes were high as the candidates made their pitch to voters. Another debate is scheduled for September 10.
Austin Steele/CNN
Biden looks at his notes during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Trump responds to a question.
Austin Steele/CNN
The candidates are seen on monitors from the side of the stage.
Austin Steele/CNN
Biden’s campaign won a coin toss before the debate to choose which side he would stand on. Trump’s campaign then chose for the former president to deliver the last closing statement.
Austin Steele/CNN
Trump answers a question during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Biden addresses Trump directly during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Bash and Tapper are seen during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Biden answers an early question.
Austin Steele/CNN
No props or pre-written notes were allowed on the stage. Candidates were given a pen, a pad of paper and a bottle of water.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
A camera captures the debate from CNN’s Atlanta studios.
Austin Steele/CNN
Trump speaks during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Tapper looks at his notes during the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
The debate rules are explained before Biden and Trump took the stage.
Austin Steele/CNN
Tapper and Bash prepare for the debate on Thursday.
Tristen Rouse/CNN
Supporters of independent candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. protest outside the White House on Thursday. They were upset that Kennedy was not invited to the debate.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
MJ Lee, senior White House correspondent for CNN, prepares for a live shot in Atlanta before the debate.
Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images
Biden greets supporters outside his hotel in Atlanta on Thursday.
Megan Varner/Reuters
Trump arrives in Atlanta on Thursday.
Tristen Rouse/CNN
Kennedy supporter Burk Stringfellow protests outside the White House on Thursday.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Debate banners hang from McCamish Pavilion across the street from the CNN campus in Atlanta.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Satellite dishes are seen at CNN’s Atlanta headquarters on Monday.
Often, presidential debates are remembered for visual moments that become embedded in the collective public consciousness in subsequent days. Troublingly for Biden, a viewer only paying attention to visual clues would surely have formed the impression that Trump was the more robust personality. And the history of presidential elections suggests that the candidate who seems strong often beats the one who is weak.
“It’s painful. I love Joe Biden,” said Van Jones, a CNN political commentator. “He’s a good man, he loves his country, he’s doing the best that he can. But he had a chance … tonight to restore confidence of the country and of the base and he failed to do that. And I think there are a lot of people who are going to want to see him take a different course now.”
Vice President Kamala Harris led attempts to turn the focus away from the optics of Biden’s performance to the threat posed by his Republican opponent.
“Yes, there was a slow start, but it was a strong finish,” Harris told CNN’s Anderson Cooper following the debate. “And what became very clear through the course of the night is that Joe Biden is fighting on behalf of the American people. On substance, on policy, on performance, Joe Biden is extraordinarily strong.”
“People can debate on style points. But ultimately, this election and who is the president of the United States has to be about substance. And the contrast is clear. Look at what happened during the course of the debate. Donald Trump lied over and over and over again as he is wont to do,” she said.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Former President Donald Trump and President Joe Biden debate at CNN’s Atlanta studios on June 27, 2024.
Harris is correct in her assessment of Trump’s cascade of untruths. And as the debate wore on, the president did seem to get a little stronger. He was especially animated when he spoke about Trump’s threat to democracy. He was scathing about the ex-president’s failure to admit defeat four years ago. “You can’t stand the loss,” Biden said. “Something snapped in you when you lost the last time.” And in an extraordinary moment in a debate before millions of television viewers, Biden highlighted Trump’s conviction in his hush money trial in New York.
“How many billions of dollars do you owe in civil penalties for molesting a woman in public? For doing a whole range of things? Of having sex with a porn star on the night – while your wife was pregnant?” Biden asked Trump. “You have the morals of an alley cat.”
The former president was found guilty last month of 34 counts of falsifying business records in his criminal hush money trial. Last year, a jury found him liable for sexual abuse in a civil defamation suit. And Trump, his adult sons and the Trump Organization lost a huge civil fraud trial, also in New York.
But the problem for Biden was that his best moments of the night came deep into the 90-minute showdown, by which time most viewers would have formed strong impressions.
And at times, he appeared unable to defend his record or effectively expose Trump’s torrent of falsehoods and distortions of his own first-term legacy. The president only briefly flashed his beaming smile, which he had effectively used to debunk Trump’s absurd arguments in their debate four years ago and when he rhetorically dismembered Republican vice presidential nominee Paul Ryan during the 2012 vice presidential debate.
If the cacophony of behind-the-scenes venting by Democrats coalesces into more serious questions about Biden’s capacity, the crisis around him will deepen. But it is hard to see any easy way — apart from a decision by the president not to accept the party nomination – that there could be any change to the Democratic ticket.
And any decision to try and replace a president who has successfully run the table in Democratic nominating contests would be unprecedented in the modern age and might end up dividing the party — a step that in itself could help Trump become only the second president to win a non-consecutive second term.
There has been little effort by the Biden White House to promote Harris as the president’s heir — and she has significant political problems of her own. And no Democrat with future presidential possibilities — for instance, California Gov. Gavin Newsom or Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer — took the risk of challenging an incumbent who once presented himself as a bridge to the future of the party.
Biden is not the first president to have a bad debate — although his ordeal on Thursday far surpasses the misfires by Barack Obama and Ronald Reagan. Both those presidents bounced back the next time they got the chance on the debate stage and went on to win a second term. But while a second debate with Trump is scheduled for September, it is hard to find a tactical rationale for the ex-president to offer his rival a do-over.
One Democratic operative summed up the president’s debate for CNN’s Kasie Hunt with a word that now threatens to encapsulate his entire reelection bid unless Biden can turn the story around.
“Horrific,” the person said.
